What game should i get next?

i really like the gta games for the ps2, i hated gta4. i wanna get a game like these types. i loved the godfather the dons edition for ps3 and ive played the scarface game(but wasn't too much a fan). which other games for PlayStation (2or3 it doesn't matter) do you think ill enjoy.. im scared to just jump out there and get some random game that sucks so any recommendations would be great